Among the collieries served by this railway were those of the Ponthenry
and Pentremawr Colliery Companies who were anxious to have men taken
daily to their pits, as there were no houses for them in the vicinity.
As the railway was in the hands of a Receiver and unable to invest,
the Colliery Companies agreed that they should each purchase a railway
coach and hire them out to the Railway Company. In return the railway
agreed, when the Receivership was discharged, to purchase the carriages
from the Colliery Companies at cost price. Supplied by the Ashbury
Railway Carriage Company they were apparently rather primitive bogie
tramcar-type vehicles. The charge by the railway to the Colliery
Companies was £2-10-0 per week per coach, which included the
cost of locomotive power and use of the railway. A deduction from
the men’s wages of I/- per week was made by the Colliery Companies
to cover the transport costs. These Colliers’ trains were first
run in 1898.
The Railway Company sought to get the Colliery Companies concerned
to sign a form of indemnity against loss and expenses “in consequence
of any accident to your coach or any of its inmates while running
over or being in our system ‘. But the Colliery Companies refused
to do so as they held they had no control over the state of the railway
line or the behaviour of the Company’s servants.
The Company clearly had concerns about this service and seems to
have first considered upgrading their line for passengers in August
1900, but the railway was only slowly coming out of its financial
difficulties and nothing was done. This slow reaction seems to have
been typical of the Boards conduct of business in the early 20th
century when the financial bottom line and an eye to high dividends
seem always to be the deciding factors.
However on the 6th September 1903 their complacency was stirred,
if not shaken, when an accident occurred between a workmen’s
train and an engine near Burry Port. It transpired that colliers’ wives
and other people were also permitted to travel by these trains. The
line was not however passed by the Board of Trade for the carriage
of passengers and no passenger duty was paid in respect of them.
It appears that this accident was duly reported at the time to the
Board of Trade who replied on the 23rd September 1903 “I am
to draw attention to the responsibility incurred by your Company
in carrying persons in this manner without the proper safeguards
adopted for passenger lines.’’ Mr Arthur Morgan, the
very capable General Manager of the Railway, subsequently called
upon Colonel Yorke at the Board of Trade on Tuesday, February 16th
1904. He explained that his Company were running workmen’s
trains up and down to the Collieries each day and that in these trains
people other than workmen were travelling. He stated that it was
the practice for parties going to Llanelly Market to ride in the
Brake Vans and if they carried any luggage a charge of 6d. per package
was made for the luggage only. Colonel Yorke said in reply that the
Board of Trade could not recognise the practice of carrying outsiders.
He did not however formally ban the practice, simply, and pointedly,
remarking that if any fatal accident occurred a great deal would
depend upon the verdict of the jury. The matter rested for a while
in this rather unsatisfactory manner and the Board returned to its
successful concentration on earning profits.
The Board came under increasing pressure from local residents
but it was still saying in May 1907 that it had no money to effect
improvements.
However with improving
finances and steady increases in traffic the railway began at last
to seriously consider putting its house in
order and in March 1908 agreed to ‘consider’ the matter.
The Board decided to seek costings for obtaining a Light Railway
order and reconstruction of the line both for passengers and overall
greater efficiency. They resolved that an ‘Engineer of experience …should
be consulted‘. By their next meeting in May they had called
in Holman Stephens as that engineer. It was reported that Morgan
had already opened negotiations with ‘Ward’ (presumably
T W Ward) for suitable coaches. Stephens with his customary speed
and efficiency reported to the July meeting. The Solicitors were
then instructed to apply for an order for the line from Burry Port
to Pontyberem.
As an existing railway wishing to improve its facilities and with
Stephens at the helm the order went through very smoothly. It was
submitted in November and granted in February 1909. Preparations
had already commenced and Stephens had undertaken the detailed survey
and made recommendations as to stock etc. With the legislation in
place the line was rapidly and extensively reconstructed in the classic
Stephens style. Track was replaced, curves eased, signalling upgraded
and stations built at minimal cost. This had been estimated at a
very reasonable £8500 and came out at £8656, a tribute
to Stephens professionalism .The line was opened for passenger traffic
on August Bank Holiday (2nd August) 1909. It was a great success
with 10000 passengers carried in the first month and 57000 in the
first half year. Another loco and more carriages were rapidly ordered.
During the reconstruction period the Board had been under great
pressure to extend the improvements and passenger service to Cwmmawr.
They had deferred the decision, only to return to it in June 1910
following consultations with Stephens, who submitted a formal report
in September. This matured into full plans and specifications in
March 1911 and another LRO submitted. Stephens appears far from
keen on this extension for the work went against his basic light
railway
engineering instincts. The
original line had severe gradients, variously reported but probably
1 in 32 with, in parts, 1 in 14 and
15. Difficult
even for mineral traffic operation and quite impossible for passenger
traffic. Reconstruction needed extensive earthworks with a cutting
one-quarter mile in length and reconstruction for 1000 yards or
more with the embankment raised 30 feet above the old trackbed. Stephens
suggested reviving an earlier projected line north to the LNWR
Carmarthen
line at Llanatheney for which authorisation had been obtained in
1881. He said it would be much cheaper to build than reconstructing
the old line, which might be retained purely for mineral traffic.
His suggestion was however not accepted either for practical operating
or political (connection with the LNWR would have upset the GWR)
reasons. The order for the extension to Cwmmawr was granted and
work commenced in October. Some work such as the second platform
at Pontyberem
was quickly finished but the remainder undoubtedly caused problems
and the directors considered reducing costs by steepening the gradients
but were deterred by Board of Trade requirements. The extension
was finally opened for passengers on 29th January 1913 at a cost
of £4000.
On 18th January, shortly before the opening, Stephens had written
that he was ‘finishing my work’ and gave great praise
to Mr Eager ‘the excellent resident engineer who has carried
out my wishes’.
This
may have been a propitiatory farewell as John Eager had been engineer
of the railway since 1901, was 14
years older than Stephens and indeed had wider engineering experience.
However he did not have the ear of the Board. Earlier in the work
Stephens had been critical of Eager particularly as the work was
being carried out by direct labour and not by his preferred method
of using Contractors. Nevertheless he had effectively worked on the
reconstruction under Stephens for nearly 5 years and such a parting
tribute was a good example both of Stephens’ patrician attitudes
and his generosity. With this parting letter Stephens seems to have
severed his connections with the Burry Port. He had his hands very
full particularly with East Kent and was no doubt glad to relinquish
some of his responsibilities in South Wales although he continued
to be involved in the nearby and ultimately unsuccessful, Gower scheme
for another ten years.
With Stephens planned reconstruction the Burry Port had
however been put on a sound engineering basis. It continued to be handicapped
by a restricted loading gauge arising from its canal origins but
latterly this was down to company parsimony. Although reconstruction
was again considered in1919 it was characteristically deferred. By
this time the railway was carrying 187,000 passengers and 355,000
colliers a year. The Company had settled down to returning a steady
10% to its shareholders and was as prosperous as any in the land.
The directors watched their returns assiduously. As a locally managed
Light Railway the Ministry of Transport offered them continued independence
at Grouping. However, astute as ever, they were approached by the
GWR with a generous offer and allowed themselves to be absorbed.
Although latterly hard hit by buses running direct to the main destination
of Llanelly passenger services nevertheless continued for another
40 years. Heavy coal traffic continued until the Coal Mining industry
eventually died in the late twentieth century.
Sources
PRO records in particular BPGV Board Minutes at RAIL89/1-2, RAIL
1110/46 and RAIL 1057/448
